How to choose an influencer marketing platform?

Choosing the right influencer platform isn’t a day’s game. Not all platforms are built the same. Each platform has its features and capabilities.
With multiple options available, at times becomes overwhelming to select the right influencer marketing platform for your brand-specific needs.

In this article, I will break down a 10-point checklist with some smart questions to help you make an informed decision.

Influencer Discovery

Well, one of the most important reasons why you are looking for an influencer marketing platform is to get access to a wide pool of influencers to choose from.

Finding the right creators is crucial for any influencer campaign. When assessing a platform’s discovery capabilities, consider:

• How big is the platform’s influencer database?
• Does it cover multiple social media platforms? What search filters does it offer?
• Can you search by specific criteria like niche, audience size, or engagement rate?
• Does it use AI to recommend the right influencers?

Why it matters: A robust search tool can save you countless hours of manual searches and help you find the perfect match for your brand that you might otherwise have missed.

Example in action: Let’s say you’re a sustainable skincare brand targeting eco-conscious millennials.
With an advanced identification tool, you can instantly identify which beauty influencers are most likely to talk about sustainability, among engaging audiences in your target age group, and have promoted similar products in the past. This targeted approach increases the likelihood of a successful partnership.

In-depth Influencer Evaluation

Once you’ve identified potential influencers, you need tools to evaluate their fit for your brand and campaign objectives.

• Does the platform provide a detailed business description for each influencer?
• Can you identify the size of the audience and the mindset of an influencer?
• Does it provide tools to identify fake followers or engagements?
• Can you see an influencer collaborating with previous brands?
• Does it provide a sentiment analysis of the influencer’s content and audience engagement?

Why it’s important: Fair pricing helps ensure you’re dealing with influencers who actually engage with your brand and reach your target audience effectively.

Example in action: Imagine evaluating two fashion influencers with the same number of followers.
Influencer A has a high share, but if you dig deeper you may find that a large portion of their audience is outside of your target market. Influencer B has a slightly lower share, but its audience is well-aligned with your target demographic and shows genuine interest consistently. This in-depth analysis will help you choose Influencer B, despite page-level metrics supporting Influencer A.

Creator Metrics

Understanding the performance and impact of potential designers is essential to successful influencer marketing campaigns.

• Does the platform offer comprehensive analytics on engagement rates, follower growth, and content performance?
• Can you see the demographic breakdown of the audience (age, gender, location)?
• Does it offer a brand appeal analysis of previous collaborations and endorsements?
• Is there an emotional assessment of the creator’s content and audience interaction?
• Can you get historical campaign performance data?

Why it’s important: These metrics give you a comprehensive view of the designer’s impact and potential impact on your brand. They help make data-driven decisions when choosing influencers and predict potential partnership success.

Example in action: By analyzing a tool’s brand affinity and previous collaborations, you can find that while Influencer A has a large following, Influencer B has a history of successful partnerships with brands that live as to your own This insight can lead you to choose Influencer B, as a result, It is likely to lead to a more realistic and effective campaign.

Campaign Management and Workflow Tools

Efficient campaign management is crucial for scaling your influencer marketing efforts. Look for platforms that offer comprehensive workflow tools.

• Does the platform include an integrated CRM for managing influencer relationships?
• What management and management tools does it offer?
• Can you negotiate and execute contracts within the platform?
• Does it handle influencer payments?
• Are there any approved tools?

Why it matters: A well-designed business plan can significantly reduce the time and effort required to manage multiple influencer partnerships simultaneously.

Example in action: Let’s say you’re running a holiday campaign with 50 influencers. Without the right tools in place, tracking contracts, product approvals, post-scheduling, and payments can be a logistical nightmare.
With a comprehensive platform, it’s easy to see which influencers have signed contracts, who have submitted comments for approval, who have a post due soon, and who needs to be paid – all from a single dashboard.

Campaign Compatibility

Ensuring creatives align with your brand values ​​and campaign objectives is essential to true influencer partnerships.

• Does the platform offer brand safety security checks to investigate controversial products or practices?
• Is there any content style and voice analytics that match the brand voice?
• Can it provide affinity scoring to determine how well a creator will work for your specific campaign?
• Does it provide a shared audience for research to avoid retargeting?

Why it matters: These features help you identify developers who not only have the right metrics but also best align with your brand’s values ​​and target audience. This system provides more accurate information and better campaign results.

Example at work: You are a sustainable fashion brand looking for influencers. Analysis of the content of the sessions shows that Influencer A frequently discusses environmental topics and has a high affinity for sustainability-related topics. Even if Influencer B has more followers, this insight can allow you to choose Influencer A for a more authentic and impactful campaign.

Comprehensive Analytics and Reporting

Measuring the success of your campaigns is crucial for optimizing your influencer marketing strategy over time.

• Does the platform offer real-time performance tracking across multiple social platforms?
• Can you track conversions and sales thanks to influencer content?
• What does the engagement metric measure?
• Are reporting dashboards customizable?
• Does it provide comparative competition?

Why it’s important: Detailed analytics help you understand what works, what doesn’t, and how to improve campaigns in the future.

Example in action: After running a campaign, you notice that while Influencer A held the most audience, Influencer B drove the biggest sales. Then Influencer C had the highest engagement rate but few click-throughs to your site.

These insights will help you fine-tune your influencer selection and content strategy for future campaigns, perhaps focusing on more conversion-oriented content with influencers like B.

Integration Capabilities

To be effective, your influencer marketing platform must integrate well with your existing marketing technology stack.

• Does the platform provide API access?
• Can it integrate directly with major social media platforms?
• Does it integrate with eCommerce platforms to track sales?
• Can it synchronize data with your main CRM?
• Is it compatible with popular project management tools?

Why it matters: A simple integration can give you a comprehensive view of your marketing efforts and streamline your workflow.

Example in action: By integrating your influencer platform with the basic CRM into your eCommerce system, you can track the customer’s journey from the first interaction with an influencer post, through their purchase, and with them with the long-term brand relationship.

This data can help you understand the overall impact of your influencer partnership beyond just instantaneous sales or engagement metrics.

Influencer Relationship Management

Building strong and long-lasting relationships with influencers can lead to more authentic partnerships and better outcomes.

• Does the platform have built-in communication tools?
• Can you trace the history of your interactions with each influencer?
• Are there any tools to segment and categorize influencers?
• Can you add custom fields to influencer profiles?
• Does it offer automatic notification features?

Why it matters: Effective relationship management can lead to more successful and long-lasting partnerships with influencers. Loyal influencers tend to be more accurate and may be more willing to cooperate in a new campaign.

Example in action: By keeping detailed records of your interactions and engagement, you can note that some influencers consistently outperform others, either in terms of engagement or conversion.
This insight can allow you to create a VIP influencer program, offering these top performers exclusive benefits or first access to new content, thus strengthening these valuable relationships.

Budget and ROI Tracking

Managing your influencer marketing budget is essential to demonstrating the value of your efforts to stakeholders.

• Does the platform provide tools to allocate and track your budget?
• Can ROI be calculated for individual influencers and campaigns?
• Does it show how the work will be done?
• Can it calculate metrics like cost per engagement?

Why it matters: These tools help you demonstrate the value of your influencer marketing efforts and optimize your spending. They can guide budget allocation decisions and help justify increased investment in successful strategies.

Example in action: By tracking detailed ROI metrics, you can see that although micro-influencers typically have a cost per post, they typically deliver no engagements or few value-per-acquisitions than macro influencers this insight Can lead you to reallocate your budget and focus more on the number of micro-influencer partnerships.

Comparative research

Comparing campaigns and creators is key to optimizing future strategies and maximizing ROI.

• Does the platform offer comparability with industry standards and competitors?
• Can you conduct research across multiple campaigns to identify best practices and areas for improvement?
• Is there a benchmark for employee performance to determine peak performance?
• Does it provide historical data analysis for trend spotting and strategy refinement?

Why it matters: Comparative analysis helps you understand your performance in context, identify what works best, and continuously improve your influencer marketing strategy.

Example in action: After running multiple campaigns, you use the platform’s comparative analysis tools to find that video content consistently performs better than static posts across all of your campaigns.
Also, you may find that manufacturers who post behind-the-scenes products generate more interest than those who only display the final product. This insight can inform your content development for future campaigns, allowing you to prioritize video content and encourage more follow-up content from your influencers.

How do you make the final decision?

When choosing an influencer marketing platform, consider:

Does the platform align with your specific goals and needs?

Think about your main goal. Are you focused on brand awareness, car sales, or community building? Make sure the platform can match your goals.

Is it in your budget?

The platform features can deliver not only the upfront costs but also the potential ROI.
Can your team make the most of all its resources?
A stage with all the bells and whistles doesn’t help if it’s too complex for your team to use effectively. Consider learning style and training resources available.

Will it scale with your project as it grows?

Consider your long-term influencer marketing strategy. Will this platform support your needs as your practice expands?

What do other users say about the platform experience?

Look for case studies, testimonials, and independent research to understand real-world experiences with the platform.

Remember, the best platform for you is one that not only meets your current needs but can also adapt as you develop your influencer marketing strategy.

Ask yourself these questions and make an informed decision.

 

Want to see things in action? Request a demo.